Constant optimism is a façade and can only last so long in the face of a constant stream of hardships, setbacks, and injustices. Eventually, it will fade when a depressive reality contradicts it. The demand for positivity places an unrealistic burden on individuals to find silver linings, even in situations where it’s neither possible nor appropriate.
To be constantly optimistic is to suppress the true emotions that lie beneath. Negative emotions will always eventually come to the boil and seep out if they are not directly acknowledged and tamed, just like a saucepan of pasta in water that gets hotter and hotter-eventually, the water will rise, and a bubbling froth will form. Feeling negative emotions is not something to be ashamed of. Our highly work-focused, bootstraps culture expects us to be machines and to carry on in the face of blatant terror, stigmatising any expression of pessimistic realities, whether personal, like mental health disorders, or society-wide. There is something to be said for keeping calm and carrying on, as was campaigned during the Second World War during the Blitz, a concept which became a prevalent meme in modern culture. But we cannot ignore the realities we face as a species, as a society, or our individual negative realities and setbacks; our problems. To not acknowledge them is to not progress beyond them.
Insisting on unbending positivity oversimplifies human experience, denying individuals the opportunity to fully process and learn from their emotions. Now, this is not a defence of wallowing in constant misery. Indeed, it is no easy feat, but changing one’s approach to thinking is vital upon realising negative realities. A stoic approach, of indifference, contentment, and the acceptance of the reality of a situation, sprinkled with the cynical realisation of the worst of humanity and how much of it is out of your sole control, acts as more of an alleviation than the almost religious-like faith of optimism.
From the book, The Post-Optimist’s Manifesto.






