The Case for Humility in Politics Over Stubborn Ideals
“Trying to give something for everyone,” was a jibe former prime minister Rishi Sunak used against the then leader of the opposition, Keir Starmer, in one of the televised debates before the 2024 general election. Nonetheless, this is the typical “you don’t stand for anything” sneer I hear so often in the polarised political world of our time. The question to ask in response to this is: is it vital to stand for something to the point where reality stares you in the face, yet you continue to hold a belief that contradicts that reality? Wouldn’t inflexibly “standing for something” get in the way of necessary change-change that is always inevitable-when and where it’s needed? Standing for something, for values, for principles, just for the sake of identity, can only hinder that change. And a hindrance to change is a hindrance to progress.
Should we continue to “stand for something” out of principle even when it is epistemologically incorrect, when it is proven wrong and untruthful? Only a traditionalist or the masses would deny this inevitability when confronted with it. Luckily for progress, traditionalists don’t always win and are often overridden by the next generation. However, a crowd, a herd, or a collective is much harder to shake.
A syncretic, non-ideological, political position is not fixed-and it is better that it isn’t. As a political observer, I so-called ‘stand for’ open-mindedness to change over rigid resistance, open discussion of ideas over disregard and ignorance, a sensible syncretic political system over tribalistic polarisation, and an acceptance of facts and a scientific approach to politics rather than ideology.
But here’s the thing: political humility-something too few are willing to allow-is a necessary and often misunderstood virtue. In a world riddled with complexity, uncertainty, and shifting circumstances, to assume one ideology holds all the answers is pure hubris. The rigidity of ideologies assumes certainty, but uncertainty is the real constant. To embrace uncertainty, to admit that no political system, no set of values, no grand ideological movement has all the answers, is not weakness-it is prudence. It’s a recognition that the future is not written, and we are not infallible. Political humility is about understanding that the world changes, and so must our responses to it. What was confirmed yesterday might not hold today. A position that refuses to adapt to new realities is a position in decline. Real progress doesn’t come from clinging to yesterday’s solutions, but from the willingness to say, “We don’t know it all, but we’re willing to find out.”
I stand for not severely standing for anything, except for being tolerant of an ever-changing world and adapting to it accordingly. Politicians-shills and salespersons in their own right-are rarely consistent. But consistency, if it means dogmatically sticking to a failing narrative, is a poor substitute for integrity. True integrity does not lie in unwavering adherence to an ideology, but in the capacity to evolve in response to new information. Integrity is not about inflexibility; it’s about being honest with oneself and with the people one serves. An individual or a politician can maintain their integrity by being open to change, by revisiting their stance when the facts demand it. It’s not a betrayal of principle to admit error or shift position-it is a testament to the honesty of one’s character.
But don’t mistake flexibility for vulnerability. A lack of flexibility, a refusal to engage with new evidence, is the real betrayal-not only of progress, but of the very integrity these politicians and ideologues claim to possess. In the cut-throat, divisive world of politics, it is rare to find true integrity. It is even rarer to see it paired with the flexibility necessary for meaningful change. But the future demands it. In the face of new evidence, new challenges, and the inexorable march of time, those who rigidly “stand for something” without ever questioning it-without ever adapting-will be left behind.
From the book, The Rise of the Radical Right.






