Critics of koinorealism and cynicism often mistakenly believe these outlooks cause isolation. They think the koinorealist’s view is the root of their suffering, when, in fact, the clarity arrived first and the distance came after. I argue the opposite: people become koinorealists after witnessing the darker aspects of human nature. These critics, the anti-koinorealists, may lack the life experiences necessary to understand hardship, experiences koinorealists often have due to the actions of others. This lack of experience can hinder their ability to cope with adversity, leading to emotionally driven reactions rather than reasoned responses.
Critics of realists that see human behaviour for what it is, warts and all, show examples of a just-world fallacy. It’s a defensive mechanism, an attempt to maintain a utopian view of humanity rather than seeing its true sketchy sociopsychological nature. A general disappointment with humankind doesn’t arise from nowhere; it stems from experiencing the true nature of our species. Cynics and koinorealists see humanity without denial, informed by their experiences and reflections, free from over-optimistic bias.
Humans can be inherently vindictive, insincere, fickle, ignorant, cold, distrustful, unreliable, uncaring, selfish, hypocritical, vain, judgmental, intolerant, deceitful, insidious, delusional, naïve, and opportunistic, among other things. Given this, it’s understandable that koinorealist cynics might grow tired of the crowd and become selective about the company they keep. I would put it more carefully than I once did, though. I used to treat withdrawal as the rational reward — the sensible refuge. What I have found instead is that the crowd is not going anywhere, and neither am I; selecting your circle is wisdom, but vanishing from the room is just the same loneliness wearing a smarter coat.
Koinorealists recognise human potential and positive achievements. However, this potential is often stifled by ignorance, idiocy, and dishonesty. Religious thinking, bad politics, and tribalism often outweigh more positive forces.
To conclude with a perhaps harsh analogy, humans are like flies: irritating, attracted to unpleasant things, and prone to over-reproduction. The company of a beloved canine and a loving romantic partner, accompanied by a book written by a human criticising humans, or a gathering with your most sound and logical-minded friends — a rarity — remains a fine evening.
From the book, The Post-Optimist’s Manifesto.






