The Fallacies and Biases Behind Polarised Thinking

Conservative ideology, like any dogmatically held worldview, often reflects patterns of flawed reasoning and cognitive distortion. While not inherently irrational, conservatism’s tendency toward rigidity and resistance to change can amplify these tendencies. However, these fallacies and biases are not exclusive to conservatism. Entrenched thinking on the left reveals similar patterns, albeit through different avenues. Examining these tendencies reveals how they manifest across the ideological spectrum.

One hallmark of conservatism is the appeal to tradition, which venerates longstanding customs simply because they have endured. While traditions can carry cultural or practical value, many are relics ill-suited to modern complexities. Similarly, status quo bias and the endowment effect reinforce conservative aversions to change by overvaluing the current state of affairs or what one already possesses.

Reactance-a backlash against perceived threats to autonomy-further sustains conservative resistance to reform, often bolstered by a collective consciousness that discourages deviation. While this phenomenon is prominent in conservative rhetoric, progressive movements also enforce conformity, particularly within insular activist circles. The dynamics of herd mentality and the false consensus effect-the tendency to align with the majority and overestimate shared viewpoints-are equally prevalent across political divides, perpetuating echo chambers on both sides.

Conservatives frequently employ the false dilemma fallacy, framing choices as stark binaries: preserve the status quo or face catastrophe. This oversimplification stifles nuanced debate, much like the slippery slope argument, which posits that small changes inevitably lead to disastrous outcomes. Such fear-based tactics often overlap with the availability heuristic, where vivid or isolated examples-such as spikes in crime-are exaggerated to reinforce opposition to reform.

The confirmation bias-seeking information that supports pre-existing beliefs while ignoring contradictory evidence-is a universal cognitive pitfall, pervasive in all partisan circles. Similarly, the sunk cost fallacy-clinging to failed efforts or disregarding new evidence-encourages a reluctance to reevaluate entrenched systems, whether in conservative policies or progressive approaches.

Psychological theories like system justification-rationalising existing social arrangements-often describe conservative thought, as these tendencies defend inequitable structures as fair or beneficial. Progressives, however, are not immune to such rationalisations when safeguarding policies they deem indispensable. The just world fallacy-believing success or failure results solely from personal effort-can underpin conservative resistance to addressing systemic inequalities.

Traits like dogmatism and the need for cognitive closure-marked by a preference for certainty and resistance to ambiguity-tend to be more pronounced in conservative ideologies, adopting an aversion to complexity. Even so, progressives can exhibit similar tendencies when ideological purity is prioritised over debate. Terror management theory, which links mortality reminders to increased adherence to worldviews, explains why crises often bolster traditionalist attitudes.

Cognitive traps like denialism and loss aversion-refusing to accept facts or prioritising loss avoidance over potential gains-underpin resistance to change across the spectrum. Conservatives often oppose emerging reforms or technologies perceived as a threat. Lastly, social dominance orientation-a preference for hierarchical structures-commonly aligns with conservative values and perpetuates the problems of economic inequality, cronyism and group egotism.

Whilst these patterns of illogical thinking are not exclusive to any ideology, the list is still strikingly pervasive within the rhetoric, policies, and tendencies of the extreme conservative spectrum, particularly the radical right.

From the book, The Rise of the Radical Right.