Our species has a fundamental potential for great evil, deep in the innateness of our animal mind. When people first learn of the atrocities that shake the world, such as Nazi Germany, the September 11th attacks, and the horror of vast serial killers (among others), they may ask the questions:

From a simplistic perspective, the answer is that these people are individualistically, ideologically, or ambitiously evil. While these reasons are indeed true, I do not think it is as straightforward as that. Pointing one’s finger to a concept of mystical vagueness like moral evilness is a quick escape for those overly optimistic about the moral nature of humanity. In other words, they think that only a certain type of person has this sense of evilness in them.

Compared to the average person, murderous tyrants possess a unique ability to do whatever is necessary to achieve their aims. The general public in history has often been complicit during the rule of their capricious leaders. Consequently, they will deny any wrongdoing of the charismatic leaders that they hold in high regard, thus indirectly allowing the continuation of atrocities under the regime they support.

People themselves have deeply held beliefs, some of which may be morally questionable. So, if the leaders they support are satisfying these beliefs by policy, they will continue to vote for them based on that one strong belief, while ignoring the rest. Voters will always be biased, selfish, and selective.

But, let’s go further. In hindsight, people often declare that they’d do XYZ in the ABC scenario:

Individuals often claim that, in a stressful situation, their judgment would have been morally superior and pristine. They ignore the emotions that are dominant in these situations. They overestimate their reasoning and sense-processing abilities under stress. They presuppose a degree of knowledge about the situation after the actual situation. To clarify the above assertions, this mental phenomenon is akin to the hindsight bias.

From the book, Denial.