When Protest Becomes Performance

Activism for activism’s sake has become a defining feature of modern student culture, but this phenomenon often reveals more about the performative nature of protest than a true commitment to change. Students, increasingly drawn to causes, often take to the streets-or the social media battlegrounds-without fully understanding the issues at hand. In their rush to align with what they perceive to be the right side of history, many fail to engage critically with the complexities of the causes they champion. This ignorance is compounded by the performative sanctimony and conformity that drive much of their activism. For some, protesting is less about confronting real injustices and more about securing a sense of moral superiority-a way to wear righteousness like a badge, without fully understanding the consequences of the policies they support.

This tendency is particularly evident when protests are framed as urgent battles against perceived injustices. However, many of these protests do not address the deep-rooted, systemic problems they claim to fight against. Instead, they focus on issues that may be exaggerated, misunderstood, or based on a misguided interpretation of what constitutes discrimination. Protesters often react to perceived injustices, but these perceptions are frequently based on a shallow understanding of a situation they have little direct association with. As a result, activism becomes an outlet for emotional release, rather than a genuine effort to understand all sides of an argument. It devolves, in many cases, into a protest for the sake of protesting-an attempt to claim moral righteousness without contributing to meaningful change.

Ironically, both sides of the political spectrum-whether left or right-have come to believe, with a conviction bordering on the absolute, that they are morally superior to the other. This belief is not merely a matter of ideological disagreement but has evolved into a profound divide in how individuals see themselves in relation to the world. Each side champions inflexible values, convinced that these values reflect a deeper understanding of justice and morality, which they view as the only legitimate moral framework.

On the left, this sense of superiority often stems from self-identification as defenders of equality, human rights, and social progress. For many on the left, the belief in progressive causes-whether it’s climate change, gender equality, or racial justice-becomes a moral imperative. The left positions itself as the standard-bearer of compassion, enlightenment, and empathy, viewing any opposition as racist, sexist, or akin to far-right ideology. In this view, rejecting these causes is to reject morality itself, to abandon the fight for the underprivileged, and to side with oppression. Those who do not align with these ideals are, in this narrative, morally deficient.

Conversely, the right claims moral superiority through its commitment to tradition, order, and personal responsibility. For conservatives, their belief in upholding time-honoured values-protecting family, religion, and nation-forms the bedrock of their moral vision. They argue that the left’s progressive agenda undermines societal stability and dilutes the virtues that have built successful civilisations. To them, the left’s advocacy for change represents a moral failing, as it threatens the very foundations of society. It is the left’s embrace of chaos and moral relativism that they see as putting society’s moral fabric at risk. Thus, the right views itself as the protector of a higher, more timeless moral order.

This mutual belief in moral superiority not only exacerbates political polarisation but also breeds a toxic sense of moral absolutism. Both sides, in their self-righteousness, become unwilling to engage with or even acknowledge the validity of the other’s moral framework. The result is a kind of ideological arms race, where each side vies for the mantle of moral authority, resorting to demonisation of the other’s beliefs. Instead of fostering dialogue or understanding, this dynamic locks both sides in a perpetual struggle over who holds the moral high ground, with little room for nuance or compromise.

The more both sides believe in their moral infallibility, the more they contribute to a cycle of division. In their quest to prove their superiority, they lose sight of the broader moral question: how to build a society that is just, equitable, and capable of reconciling competing values and perspectives. What might have been an honest pursuit of virtue is instead weaponised ideology that alienates and polarises rather than unites.

Many modern activists romanticise the protests and movements of earlier generations, seeking to replicate the energy and moral clarity that once defined those struggles. The civil rights movements, anti-war protests, and labour strikes of the 20th century stand as symbols of necessary activism-battles fought against systemic oppression, entrenched inequality, and outright injustice. These past movements, with their life-or-death stakes, are imbued with historical significance and purity. Activists today, in a world that they’d deny to be more just than before, are drawn to these examples, believing that by emulating the same tactics, they too can contribute to societal change and, perhaps, define a legacy of their own.

However, the issues being protested today do not carry the same weight or urgency as those of the past. The social and political landscape has shifted, and many of the problems that once sparked mass uprisings-such as racial segregation, colonialism, or state-sanctioned violence-have either been addressed or evolved into more complex, nuanced challenges. In their place, many of today’s causes revolve around issues that, while important, may not be as problematic as they seem. Gender-neutral bathrooms, symbolic gestures of “inclusivity,” or hyper-legalistic battles over cultural appropriation, for example, have become rallying cries for a generation that, in many ways, enjoys freedoms and rights that earlier activists could only dream of.

In their zeal to recreate the passion and significance of past movements, many activists focus on what could be considered non-issues by the wider public, or issues that are primarily cultural rather than structural. The problem is not the issues themselves, but the tendency to elevate them to the level of existential crisis. These protests risk becoming performance activism, where the symbolic act of protesting becomes more important than the substance of the cause. Instead of tackling the systemic issues that still need addressing-such as economic inequality, climate change, or human rights abuses-activists channel their energies into matters that do not provoke the same urgency or widespread impact.

In this way, the desire to replicate the revolutionary fervour of past struggles misses the point of those movements in the first place. Rather than addressing the pressing challenges of the present, it becomes an exercise in self-congratulation-a way to feel part of a larger, heroic narrative without confronting the more complex, less glamorous work of actual societal change. By choosing to protest issues that are often symbolic rather than substantive, activists risk turning their movements into hollow echoes of past glories-activism disconnected from the real, life-and-death concerns of the world around them.

From the book, The Rise of the Radical Right.