The notion that humans are inherently sensible beings is a pervasive myth. Beneath the veneer of conscious thought lies a complex chemistry of biases, emotions, and cognitive shortcuts that often distort our perception of reality. Most people are not familiar with any of these ingredients because it is unlikely to be introspected, as their biases will always reassert their perspectives and subjections throughout life. Even worse, if people do become informed about these inherent problems of cognition, they will scoff and deny that it is even a thing or that they will be swayed by these flaws. I shall call this phenomenon of the human condition “unconscious fallaciousness”. In short, it is the insidious belief in one’s own infallibility that hinders the ability to recognise flaws in one’s thinking.

Unconscious fallacies are cognitive errors that occur without conscious awareness. They manifest as a variety of biases, such as confirmation bias, the Dunning-Kruger effect, and the sunk cost fallacy. These cognitive distortions, deeply rooted in the fields of psychology, philosophy, and sociology, influence our judgements, decisions, and behaviours, often leading to suboptimal outcomes. For instance, confirmation bias, the tendency to seek information that confirms our existing beliefs, can impede critical thinking.

The consequences of unconscious fallaciousness are far-reaching. At an individual level, they can lead to poor decision-making, closed-mindedness, a lack of critical and analytical thinking, and a continuation of irrational beliefs, among others. On a societal scale, this unawareness of the flaws in one’s own thinking contributes to the spread of misinformation, political polarisation, science denial, social unrest and much more. Emotions, such as fear, anger, and love, can amplify the impact of these fallacies, clouding judgement and hindering rational thought.

From the book, The Post-Optimist’s Manifesto.