The bully needs the mob. Through a combination of charisma, intimidation, and perceived social value, they form their mob. This mob is not merely a group of followers; it is evidence of the bully’s social victory. The mob reeks of collective fear, with its members doing everything they can to avoid becoming its next target. Replicating the bully’s behaviour becomes one of the key ways to achieve this.

The bully’s power lies not in their individual actions, but in the collective response of the group. The mob, whether consciously or unconsciously, validates the bully’s actions. They provide the audience the bully craves, the fear they feed on, and the social validation they need to continue. In this sense, the bully wins. Without the universal acceptance of the bully’s behaviour, they would lose. Their dominance is recognised, their actions go unchallenged, and their status is elevated. Although they are a moral failure, the bully becomes a social success-and social success holds greater weight than morality in human nature.

While the bully may seem to triumph socially, their victory is both fleeting and fragile. It depends on the mob’s continued acceptance of their behaviour. Once this acceptance fades, the bully’s social dominance crumbles, revealing the hollow nature of their power.

Conformists who criticise an eccentric’s mode of being-whether it be their dress style, personal interests, speech, values, or philosophical views-are the culprits of validating the bully. Yet the crowd overlooks this culpability. They unconsciously believe that the conformist is defending social convention. Consequently, they do not see themselves as enabling or tolerating bullying behaviour. Humans have come to accept that teasing, ridiculing, and ostracising those who differ from what they are accustomed to is permissible. This, I must stress, occurs at an unconscious level within the conformist’s mind.

If I were to read this passage to a societal conformist, they would still snigger and scoff at these very observable facts. This is because the conformist is victim to the argumentum ad populum (appeal to popularity), often in conjunction with the ad verecundiam (appeal to authority-the authority being the bully who is the leader of the pack). If a popular conformist ridicules the maverick, it further reassures the followers of popularity that their opinion is correct, reaffirming their fickle, docile, socially gullible minds.

The argumentum ad populum is rampant, powerful, and omnipotent. It is devout in nature, and it is what maintains collective dogma, shared ignorance, judgementalism, hatred of dissidents, anti-intellectualism, and shallow expectations. Interestingly, the argument from popularity is temporarily steadfast, utterly committed to the current consensus or the latest fad. Once that consensus becomes outdated, the so-called “wisdom of the crowd” shifts and embraces the new consensus.

Change is valuable, but only when based on reason, progress, and empiricism-not on the notion that the crowd must be right simply because the majority believes it. A conformist may assert the phrase “wisdom of the crowd” as a positive. Yet wisdom cannot possibly exist in a crowd influenced entirely by blind submission to the herd. It is troubling how readily the average person places such immense trust in collective opinion, without a moment’s thought, solely because it is popular.

From the book, The Post-Optimist’s Manifesto.