Biases fuel the denialism so prevalent in the human psyche, as do inconsistencies in argumentation. Logical fallacies take centre stage when the denialist reacts to the revelation of their biases. When you examine a list of fallacies with their definitions, many appear synonymous with various cognitive biases. They indeed complement each other. Fallacies and biases form a close alliance in the mind of a denialist, thereby creating a false impression that their perspective is reinforced-a line of reasoning that is both flawed and distasteful.
Now I will highlight a few of the fallacies that often underpin denialism, often witnessed both in social and personal dynamics:
- A fallacy of association is the incorrect assumption that because two things share a property, they are the same. For example, assuming someone is untrustworthy because they come from a particular city known for crime.
- Argumentum ad populum, or appeal to the majority, occurs when it is assumed that something is true or better because many people believe it. An example would be claiming a brand of car is the best because everyone drives it.
- Ad hominem is an attack on the person rather than the argument they are making. For instance, saying someone can’t understand an issue because they’re not a parent.
- An appeal to tradition assumes that something is better or correct simply because it is older or has been done for a long time. An example is insisting that a method is the best because it’s always been done that way.
- Retrospective determinism is the belief that an event was inevitable just because it happened, such as claiming a team was destined to win a game because they had the better players after the fact.
- Circular reasoning occurs when the conclusion of an argument is used as a premise of the same argument, like saying, “I’m right because I say I’m right.”
- The fallacy of many questions involves asking a question that presupposes something that has not been proven or accepted, such as “Have you stopped cheating on exams?” which assumes the person has cheated before.
- An appeal to emotion is the manipulation of an emotional response in place of a valid or compelling argument. This is often seen in politics, where leaders use fear tactics to sway voters without logical reasoning.
- An argument from ignorance assumes a claim is true because it has not been proven false or vice versa, like asserting that ghosts must exist because no one has shown they don’t.
- An argument from incredulity involves doubting or rejecting a claim because it seems unbelievable or difficult to understand, such as being unable to imagine how a complex system could evolve naturally and, therefore, concluding it must have been designed.
While there are likely other fallacies worth including, I believe I’ve sufficiently made my point. These fallacies are ubiquitous. They are prevalent in maintaining the cohesiveness and rigidity of smaller social groups, workplaces, political parties, and mass cultures at large. Without this level of unreasonableness, social groups would descend into conflict, and I’d even venture to say that humanity might fail. Individuals who choose to think outside the box indeed pave the way for progress. However, that progress cannot be anticipated without the masses first accepting it as the new norm, and thus propelling it forward.
From the book, Denial.






