The Unintended Consequences of Progressivism

The past decade has seen a troubling rise in radical right-wing movements, a phenomenon that, paradoxically, has its roots in the actions of certain factions on the political left. In examining the socio-political landscape of the 2010s into the 2020s, one cannot ignore the role of an increasingly sanctimonious left that, through extreme measures, has inadvertently fuelled the very extremism it aimed to oppose.

Christopher Hitchens, in the 1990s, sat on a roundtable with feminists and raised concern about the growing infantilism prevalent on college and university campses in the U.S. This was in the 1990s, well before what we now recognise as modern “wokery,” or whatever term might be appropriate. Hitchens was also there-not literally, but virtually-standing by Salman Rushdie’s side when the left failed to defend him after his book, The Satanic Verses, was released and an Iranian Ayatollah Khomeini ordered a fatwa against him. This was the 1980s. Then, in the late 2000s, Hitchens spoke about growing concerns over the label “Islamophobia” and argued that such a disingenuous word should be resisted. Again, how could he be so prophetic? Many on the left, like Hitchens, saw identity politics coming and identified it as a matter of caution rather than promotion.

I recall a discussion with a self-described communist who said he was once a reader and admirer of the so-called New Atheists, to then later ridiculously denounce them as racists for criticising the religion of Islam. Anyone with an unsanctimonious mind could see that Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, Sam Harris and Daniel Dennett were merely critiquing an ideology, yet their detractors, like many others embroiled in identity politics and culture wars, automatically assume the ideology they critiqued to be associated with a particular race. Ben Affleck and Sam Harris had exactly that kind of confrontation on Real Time with Bill Maher. Harris said, “Islam is the motherlode of bad ideas,” and yes, before you know it, Affleck threw the accusation of racism around as if it were a dodgeball. The crowd, as frivolous as they can be in any situation, cheered for Affleck’s pious outrage. Affleck, like the radical left, seems unable to grasp that a term like “Islam” represents an ideology and “religion” is an overarching label for various other ideologies that hold supernatural beliefs. Those on the left who decry “Islamophobia” do so because they think any valid criticism of that religion is a criticism of a people, yet only recognise this distinction when someone dissects Christianity or Judaism; essentially, only when it pleases their political aims.

Many on the left became victims of the onslaught of cancellation and censorship, alongside the right-wingers and moderates they ideologically despised. Richard Dawkins, a biologist that has always espoused left-leaning political tendencies, for instance, had one of his honorary awards removed by a humanist charity because of his scientific stance on the sexes in biology. This happened long after he’d already been lambasted by many on the left for being “too harsh” on non-Western religions, just like the other New Atheists.

Throughout the 2010s, the hard left-regressive left, radical left, or whatever term you prefer-dominated public discourse, enforcing cancel culture, censorship, and demonisation of dissent. They succeeded in making the rational left look terrible. This ideological domination grew over the decades, and while much of it was well-intentioned, it was only a matter of time before all the censorship, cancelling, and virtue-signalling provoked a backlash from a growing radical right. The bear had been poked enough to provoke a serious reaction, reshaping political landscapes: the disgrace of Brexit in 2016, Donald Trump’s rise to power; the conversion of what I once perceived as left-leaning moderates like Joe Rogan and Elon Musk to support a demagogue like Trump for a second presidential term; Twitter’s transformation into “X,” a breeding ground for radical ideologies; the election of clowns like Boris Johnson in 2019; the meteoric rise of the Reform Party in the U.K. leading up to the 2024 election, where it was the third-most-voted-for party, despite being freshly formed; the anti-immigrant riots that erupted shortly after; the spread of hard-right parties across Europe; and even the shift in the Russian sociopolitical mood whereby the sophists of Russian leadership thought to embrace conservatism and Christian nationalism, a contrast to its recent revolutionary history.

The radical left has been met with the response of a radical right with the intention to go head-to-head. The right once cowered to the allegations made by the radical left, but following Brexit and beyond, their skin has grown thicker, and they began to retaliate. The left’s constant obsession with being so-called ‘woke’ and censoring opposition or calling everyone a Nazi for those who disagree, for shutting down debate on campus and beyond, has caused a recoil among the right, and a dangerous backlash indeed, with a worrying degree of growing support. Reform wanted to rip up the Equality Act as they proposed in the 2024 U.K. election. Trump re-elected to a second term despite his many disgraces, hard-right parties in Europe began to poll extremely well, and so on. The radical left, with their excessive sanctimony, was responsible, at least partially, for this pushback.

The perceived demonisation of men drove swathes of people to figures of masculinity and self-help-the “pull yourself up by your bootstraps” nonsense-from Jordan Peterson to Donald Trump. Such rhetoric has created bitterness and resentment. This kind of demonisation affects them deeply, as the idea of being rejected by society is something our species-a very social animal, might I add-are not equipped to handle. The radical right has weaponised misandry-like rhetoric from the radical left as a powerful talking point, making chauvinists like Andrew Tate popular among young men who now think it’s “cool” to be antagonistic towards women, to deny science, and embrace religious thinking. Demonising people for being by chance white, straight and male has done no favours to the left’s cause.

When policies lack nuance, people often want to fight fire with fire. They’ll propose a radical alternative out of spite, simply to counter the ideology of their political outgroup. The sense of anti-Westernism within the West has only fuelled nationalism on the right even more. It is injudicious for radicals on the left expect to keep touting that the West is so evil-so colonial, so racist, so capitalist, so oppressive-and not expect nationalists to come out with pitchforks. That’s not to say it’s without faults; all nations and regions have their faults yet contributions, strengths yet weaknesses.

Radical has met radical. This kind of dynamic has brought disaster, as seen with the attempted coup on the Capitol incited by Donald Trump and other such eruptions. Groups claiming to be anti-fascist and other hard-left factions have taken part in their own fair share of violent craziness since 2016. We saw mass protests, many peaceful but some violent, across the U.S., with smashed windows, vandalised property, scared campuses, and people attacked with bike locks. Then, the radical right groups chimed in-like the Proud Boys, the Nazis at Charlottesville, and the fanatics who threatened to hang vice-president Mike Pence-each playing their part in this cult of idiocy.

The regressive left and the reactionary right are two sides of the same coin. It’s in conservative nature to push policy and society back to a “better” time-a place of comfort. You’d think the modern left would be the opposite: embracing science, moving forward, protecting civil liberties, free speech, and open discussion. The cancel culture of the 2010s gave rise to what some have termed the “regressive left,” characterised by a paradoxical tendency to tacitly support regimes (e.g., Soviet Russia, Islamic nations enforcing sharia law) and ideologies (such as Islam and communism) that stand in opposition to the very freedoms they enjoy within democratic societies.

From the book, The Rise of the Radical Right.