Individuals who exhibit a strong in-group/out-group bias may sometimes show harsher attitudes towards animals. They might view animals as lesser beings, disconnected from humanity; in sociological terms, animals are considered part of the out-group compared to the human in-group. This lack of empathy can lead to a willingness to ignore or dismiss animal suffering, often resulting in indifference or even cruelty. For instance, a family member of mine was prepared to let pigeons trapped behind an obstruction in a chimney die rather than assist them in escaping through a door or window. Similarly, some people may prefer to squash a spider on the wall rather than capture it in a glass and release it outside.

Furthermore, individuals who prioritise human relationships and interactions might unconsciously elevate humans to a higher status, often overlooking the existence and suffering of other beings. This lack of empathy towards animal suffering can reflect a form of collective narcissism, where the value of one’s own group-in this case, humans-is exaggerated at the expense of others. Such a perspective may indicate an ingrained belief in human superiority, leading to an inability to empathise with non-human suffering and a tendency to view it as less significant or unworthy of the same care and compassion extended to humans.

Dismissive remarks like “It’s only a dog,” made in the presence of someone mourning a beloved pet, highlight this broader issue. Such comments often reflect a misunderstanding of why someone might grieve a non-human being, perceiving it as less worthy of sorrow simply because it is not part of the human in-group. However, caring for animals, pets, and even creatures with whom we have no personal connection is not a betrayal of humanity but rather an expression of our capacity for compassion. Of course, this principle does not extend to situations where self-defence is necessary against predators.

From the book, The Post-Optimist’s Manifesto.