I recently overheard a discussion between a flat earther and their opponent. This debate seemed tremendously pointless, yet they attempted to lend it credibility through the use of jargon and intellectual interrogation, questioning each other over finite volume and specific mathematical aspects of the universe, which currently go over my head. However, what they fail to realise is what truly needs to be brought into question. The methods used to reach their conclusions should be investigated, not entirely the substance. Especially if the debate is about a topic that is no longer debatable (like the geodesy of the Earth; a branch of geometry, which is the science of measuring and understanding the Earth’s geometric shape, orientation in space, and gravity field. Geodesy involves mathematical and physical principles to determine the size and shape of the Earth). No one in this online discussion was questioning the flat earther’s approach to their conclusion. Instead, they, along with the flat earther, believed that the specifics of their differing positions were more worthy of debate. Thus, as I have implied, I beg to differ.
The focus should be on the method of inquiry they are using. From their responses, one could have easily discovered that they reject much of the scientific method. Their views are formed based on pseudo-intellectualism, faith, or even herd mentality, and they do not use any viable, concrete, empirical method to reach their conclusions. This is why it is futile to debate with conspiracy theorists, flat earthers, or religious evangelicals. They do not appreciate having their flawed approach to their conclusions exposed.
I refuse to debate with most people-only a select few, maybe close friends whom I know are capable of an open mind. By capable, I mean they must be willing to use reason at all costs in debate despite disagreement. The problem with most people is that they are too emotional and can’t handle civil disagreement. Stuck in echo chambers, they are biased, fallacious, and use rhetoric. Attacking something they hold as a truth, ideal, or whatever, hurts their fragile ego. It’s often a pointless endeavour. Audiences are more attracted to the charismatic debater and will view them as having won a debate even if they are objectively wrong. Most people are stubborn, ideological, and don’t want to change their mind, especially if it goes against a convention, a status quo, a norm, or a habitual behaviour that they have been long exposed to. People want to believe what they want, no matter how unfactual it is. Debate, especially through online means like forums and similar modern communication, is a time-wasting endeavour. One’s time is better spent on other activities.
From the book, The Post-Optimist’s Manifesto.






