…and the Threat to America’s Founding Principles

In an interview on C-SPAN dated from the 1990s, Christopher Hitchens made these remarks about Donald Trump:

“It always makes me suspicious when you have these apolitical businessmen saying, well, I just want to put the country back on its feet and restore incentives and so forth. There’s something, frankly, I think, sinister about it, unless the guy’s prepared to say a great deal more about what his political opinions are. For example, has he ever voted before and for whom? I’d like to know. Because it’s much too easy, this talk, even if the country could be run like USA Inc. with a real can-do guy. There’s a whiff of fascism to that, I think.”

More than 20 years before Trump’s initial campaign, once again, Hitchens does not cease to amaze me in how he was able to notice, so early on, the paths that politics would stride at the beginning of the 21st century.

Whilst conservatives have been attempting to call out the conspiracy of a deep state and how the ‘lefties’ have been authoritarian and radical in their management of government bureaucracy and inner workings, the alternative they advocate for, and have voted for twice (2016 and 2024), is a double standard, as the Trump administration offers the same kind of authoritarianism but instead catered to the delusional radical right.

If anything like Project 2025-a combination of hard-right policy ideas originally formulated for a Donald Trump return to the presidency-were to be implemented by any incoming United States president, it would betray the nation’s very founding values. Absolute power is wholly anti-American. This would be a total tragedy. The disastrous outline of Project 2025 reveals how Republicans, blinded by their own internal contradictions, parade their ignorance. The American right is far from the libertarian ideals they claim to uphold. Their pursuit of a Christian nationalist state, which seeks to suppress those who do not adhere to its religious dogma, and their desire to enforce strict civil and ideological conformity, reveal the hollowness of their so-called libertarian goals.

Author of God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything, Christopher Hitchens frequently criticised the influence of organised religion in politics and society. He saw religious orthodoxy as fundamentally opposed to the Enlightenment values upon which the United States was founded. On this theme, he allegedly remarked:

“How dismal it is to see present-day Americans yearning for the very orthodoxy that their country was founded to escape.”

Although I cannot verify the quote’s source at the time of writing, it is widely attributed to Hitchens, and given his body of work, it seems entirely characteristic of him. For now, I will engage with the sentiment it conveys.

Some may misinterpret this critique as targeting the Puritans who fled religious persecution long before the American Revolution. However, this reading overlooks the broader point he was making. While the Puritans sought refuge from persecution, they were far from champions of freedom. In fact, they established their own brand of orthodoxy and dogmatism in the New World-precisely the mindset Hitchens opposed. His frustration instead lay with a modern resurgence of evangelical conservatism and political religiosity, which he viewed as a betrayal of the Enlightenment principles of liberty and secularism enshrined in the United States Constitution. Hitchens often praised the secular foundations of the American Revolution, contrasting them with both the dogmas of the Old World and the rising influence of contemporary evangelical movements. By yearning for “orthodoxy,” Americans, in his view, undermined the revolutionary ideals championed by figures like Jefferson and Madison. This was not a critique of the Puritans themselves but of the revival of rigid, exclusionary thinking they epitomised. This analysis also extended beyond religion. For Hitchens, the resurgence of evangelical orthodoxy symbolised broader trends of anti-intellectualism and conformist thinking. Movements advocating creationism in schools, opposing same-sex marriage, or restricting abortion exemplified the retreat from the progress and freedoms that define a secular democracy; one that which the founding fathers intended to create.

Since its founding, the United States has never truly experienced a completely tyrannical government. Its very foundation was a rebellion against British tyranny in the late 1700s. The country was originally built with the aim of opposing and overthrowing tyranny. But with the rise of American populism in the 2020s, it’s clear that many are naïve to the possibility of creating tyranny by their own hands. The United States is still a relatively young country, and other nations with much longer histories have endured tyranny, fascism, and religious persecution at the hands of their own governments. As I write this in 2024, the rise, fall, and re-emergence of figures like Trump suggests that the U.S. population is unconsciously, and unknowingly, paving the way for populist leadership that in some instances resembles autocracy and with Trump’s initial cabinet picks composed of billionaires, it is difficult to deny it as a plutocratic government.

Is Trump a fascist? If anything, he and his authoritarian cronies may be akin to a form of evolved, modernised lite-fascism, since he has definitely shown tendencies towards very fascistic traits following his first term and beyond. Having said that, many scholars, historians, and his own cohort have described him as such.

Is Trump a tyrant? He is a wannabe tyrant. I believe if he had the opportunity, he would allow himself to embrace tyranny. With his ‘dictator on day one’ remark, his overall lust for authoritarianism, his desire for retribution against those he believes have wronged him, his desire to appoint Trump loyalists across the civil service, and his attempted overthrowing of the 2020 election, I have no issue calling him a wannabe tyrant. Of that, I can be more certain.

Is Trump a misogynist? I don’t usually like throwing these terms around, as the many on the left already do so at anyone they simply don’t like, but in this case, it’s an undeniable yes. The way he has spoken about women in his social circle-”grab them by the pussy, you can do anything”-and numerous other instances, which are likely easily discoverable with a closer look into his past, strongly suggest that he believes women are an inferior sex.

Is Trump a demagogue? Absolutely. His rhetoric is rife with regurgitated nonsense, lies, and conspiracies, all designed to manipulate emotions rather than encourage rational discourse. His populist appeals to “the people” versus the “elites” exacerbate division and fuel distrust in institutions. Trump embodies the very definition of a demagogue, thriving on fear and anger.

With World War II becoming a distant memory, newer generations, lacking firsthand experience, appear to be falling into the traps of the past. It seems that every century, younger generations, naturally naïve to the recent history they haven’t lived through, disregard how bad things were and fail to recognise the danger of history repeating itself.

One would be delusional to assume that humans are no longer capable of replicating the atrocities of the 1940s. Humanity will always be capable of bringing out the worst of its own nature. Wars have been fought over land, diplomatic discrepancies, mere ego, a lust for power, and religion. Any compelling nutjob can come along and rock the boat on already turbulent waters. The boat being society and cohesion, and the turbulent waters being human nature and its tendencies for madness.

With the decline in the quality of education and open discourse on important topics like history-areas that, I might add, have also been undermined by the 21st-century left through forms like cancel culture-an uninformed younger populace becomes a dangerous prospect.

It seems to me that the Western populace, unknowingly and ironically, is yearning for political upheaval. One only needs to look at the radical populists they are voting for. They are walking into a room filled with nails and booby traps, eyes firmly shut. I dearly hope I’m wrong.

From the book, The Rise of the Radical Right.