Of all things, as COVID-19 swept through the oceans and skies-still a developing crisis, yet unfolding rapidly-people rushed to supermarkets, filling their trolleys with one surprising item: toilet paper. While shelves in local stores were quickly emptied, toilet paper became the commodity of highest value for many, their collective minds overtaken by the herd mentality of mass hysteria and panic. When people see others panic-buying, they often feel compelled to do the same, even if they don’t fully understand why. It’s a cycle. They watch or read sensationalised news, which spreads across social media, and panic sets in. As you head to do your weekly shop, you see others coming out in droves with trolleys full of toilet paper. Automatically, the collective mind fallaciously assumes there must be a good reason why so many of their fellow humans are engaging in this behaviour-particularly overloading on toilet rolls-and thus feel compelled to do the same.

Moreover, there’s the fear that if everyone else is buying up all the toilet paper, there won’t be any left for them. It sounds contradictory, but it isn’t-every man for himself. It’s selfishness at play, driven by our natural herd instincts. People tend to look to others for cues on how to behave, trusting the fallacy of truth by consensus, especially in uncertain times. High-stress situations impair rational decision-making, and emotional contagion-the phenomenon by which people “catch” the emotions of others-takes hold. This leads to mindlessly following the crowd, no matter the consequences.

This same dynamic, it must be said, is at the heart of how riots begin, how populist leaders can stir hatred against particular groups, and how once, not so long ago, people thought it was right to burn those they labelled witches at the stake.

Humans are deeply fearful of the unknown. In the absence of certainty, they will fabricate it. Religions are born, conspiracies flourish, public opinion becomes disillusioned, and populist politics take root. Mass anxiety seizes society, and people cling to rigid responses to questions that cannot be answered. They seek simple, polarised solutions, shunning nuance. This fear is the fertile ground in which stupidity grows. Bad ideas are accepted, mythical ideologies emerge, and they are upheld by oppression, propaganda, and indoctrination.

Historical events, revolutions and transitions have shown that a fear of uncertainty initially stifles progress. Society and authority are rarely open to change, even when it is necessary. But the universe is ever-changing, and time-at least in our perception-moves forward, not backward. In the end, change always prevails.

From the book, The Post-Optimist’s Manifesto.