Misinformation, Disinformation, and the Internet Age

One of the many striking examples of moral panic in recent times is the 2024 anti-immigration riots that occurred in the U.K. Let’s take a moment to define moral panic. It’s a phenomenon where a group succumbs to irrational fears or behaviours, often spreading rapidly without brakes. This ties closely to herd psychology, where people’s actions and reactions are shaped by the collective mindset of those around them. The riots that I speak of were fuelled by rumours and misinformation, which spread quickly and caused widespread panic. False claims about the perpetrators of a tragic stabbing incident sparked a wave of anti-immigration sentiment and violent protests across the country. Sensationalised news coverage amplified these fears, leading to overreactions that further escalated the situation. Emotional contagion also played a considerable role in this whole ordeal, as individuals “caught” the emotions of those around them, creating a shared sense of panic and urgency.

These factors created a feedback loop, where the actions of a few escalated into a larger, more intense reaction from the group. It is remarkable how our social nature can lead to such widespread behaviours, demonstrating the power of collective psychology in shaping public reactions.

The term “fake news” was popularised by Donald Trump-ironically, one of the most prolific spreaders of fabrication, conspiracies, and so-called “alternative facts”. For Trump and his followers, “fake news” refers to any information they find inconvenient. This manipulation of language has profoundly impacted public discourse, leading to a rise in misinformation and distrust in traditional media. The rise of right-wing movements globally has been characterised by similar patterns of misinformation and disinformation, as well as the emotional manipulation necessary to embed these half-truths in the minds of potentially loyal supporters of these demagogues.

Since Musk took over Twitter (now X) in October 2022, there has been a marked increase in extreme and radical content. Musk’s changes-including mass layoffs within the content moderation team and the reinstatement of accounts tied to hate speech and conspiracy theories-have shifted the platform’s tone. Studies, including one by the Centre for Countering Digital Hate, report a marked rise in hate speech across categories like antisemitism, racism, and misogyny. In some cases, language associated with these ideologies surged by 500% shortly after Musk’s acquisition, according to research by Brookings and Tufts University. Musk’s platform, X, was temporarily banned in Brazil after it failed to comply with a court order to appoint a legal representative in the country. This requirement, which is part of Brazilian law, aims to ensure companies can be held accountable for legal matters. The suspension followed a long-standing dispute with Brazilian authorities over issues of misinformation, including the refusal to block certain accounts linked to far-right political groups. The ban was only lifted once Musk’s company complied with the court’s demands, including appointing a representative and paying outstanding fines.

The radical right wants free speech to run wild, as this suits their agenda of promoting untruths. I care about free speech, provided it primarily serves the truth. Radical conservatives are uninterested in truth-it often contradicts their beliefs. They would claim, to use one instance, that creationism should be taught in schools, and this exemplary scenario indicates where we must draw the line with the spreading of untruths. They push for unchecked free speech to circulate nonsense that they want to be true, rather than what is. Truth matters, and spreading lies under the guise of free speech is to be rebelled and call out as a deception.

Beyond policy changes, Musk’s actions-such as making blue-check verification available for a fee-have created further vulnerabilities, allowing misinformation and extremist narratives to proliferate more easily. This trend has drawn criticism from researchers and civil rights groups, who argue that these shifts not only enable but actively attract radicalised content and communities.

In the digital age, our reality is curated by algorithms with a singular agenda. These digital puppeteers prioritise sensational and emotionally charged content, exacerbating moral panic by continuously exposing users to fear-inducing, polarising information. Social media platforms, driven by profit, design these algorithms to maximise engagement, showing a blatant disregard for accuracy or balance. The result is a relentless bombardment of misinformation and emotionally charged narratives, creating an echo chamber that amplifies our fears and entrenches biases. And this activity is not exclusive to the right.

The radical left is willing to spread their agendas using the powerful tactics of information manipulation to appeal to its dull and ideological followers just as much as the radical right. This artificial amplification of hysteria has led to a society teetering on the edge of perpetual panic, manipulated by unseen digital overlords. Social media has become the bane of political discourse-no good force remains within it.

Groupthink is the death knell of rationality, where the desire for conformity within a group morphs into collective idiocy. In the realm of moral panic, groupthink is the accelerant, pushing individuals to align blindly with the dominant narrative, regardless of its basis in reality. This pressure to conform stifles dissent and critical thinking, fostering an environment where irrational decisions become the norm. This collective conformity transforms into a frenzied mass, amplifying the panic and leading to catastrophic consequences, driven by the herd’s unchallenged delusions.

History is littered with the wreckage of moral panics, each a testament to humanity’s susceptibility to manipulation and fear. Take the Red Scare in the United States during the 1950s-a period marked by McCarthyism and the ruthless persecution of supposed communists. This witch hunt was fuelled by baseless fears and a government willing to trample civil liberties in its paranoid quest for control. Fast-forward to the Satanic Panic of the 1980s, where sensationalist media reports and unfounded allegations of ritual abuse gripped the public imagination, resulting in modern-day witch hunts. Innocent lives were destroyed-all in the name of combating an imaginary threat. Nor should we forget the European witch hunts of the 16th and 17th centuries, a dark chapter where tens of thousands-mostly women-were executed in a hysterical crusade against witchcraft. These historical episodes reveal a disturbing pattern: moral panic as a tool for manipulating public opinion and reinforcing societal norms, always at the expense of truth and justice.

Moral panic, collective hysteria, and disinformation are deeply intertwined with herd psychology and emotional contagion. The 2024 anti-immigration riots by some fringe groups in the U.K. and the situation with X in Brazil illustrate how misinformation can incite widespread panic and irrational behaviour.

To address the problems of social media disinformation, one might call for greater transparency and accountability from media organisations and social media platforms. However, such reforms can only go so far when one of the largest social media companies is owned by a figure with a penchant for spreading disinformation. The case of X, now owned by Trump’s ally Elon Musk, epitomises this conundrum.

Another potential solution is for schools to teach young people how to critically evaluate, analyse, and research the information they receive from media and online sources, rather than blindly conforming to the views of a favoured outlet or celebrity. A degree of media literacy is essential in an era dominated by misinformation and disinformation, where navigating multiple sources has become a vital skill.

From the book, The Rise of the Radical Right.