Comparing Right Populism from Then to Now
The job of a demagogue is to stoke fear, manipulate uncertainties, and fuel anxiety among the populace, capitalising on insecurities perpetuated by media-driven propaganda. Demagogues are adept at presenting themselves as saviours, offering seemingly simple solutions to complex societal issues. “I will save you; I will fix it all. All we have to do is follow this simple plan, and we can reclaim our country,” they declare; disregarding the reality that policy rarely offers a one-size-fits-all remedy. Political policies inevitably benefit some groups while disadvantaging others. A responsible leader would weigh these impacts on all communities, but a demagogue prioritises immediate appeal over balanced, long-term outcomes. Many supporters of demagogues either fail to consider or simply don’t care about the impact on those outside their immediate circle. In many cases, this indifference stems from humanity’s inherently self-interested nature, which tends to disregard the unseen struggles of others.
Since the 2010s, political rhetoric has reached unprecedented levels of extremism, albeit in a form far from new. Historically, many politicians that went on to become presidents and prime ministers in the Western world exercised caution in public speech, wary of stirring inflammatory passions. This standard shifted dramatically with Donald Trump’s rise to prominence. His rhetoric-a volatile mix of simplicity, audacity, and frequently unfounded claims-has become a template for, not only other countries that are experiencing a surge of right-wing demagoguery, but also for younger generations that will probably see Trumpian behaviour as proper presidential behaviour. Conspiracies and misinformation are treated as viral memes, shared widely across social media without scrutiny. It became fashionable to embrace falsehoods and dismiss factual accuracy. For the average voter, entrenched in echo chambers and insulated by confirmation biases, recognising these lies and considering alternative perspectives proves nearly impossible. Even when confronted with undeniable truths, many refuse to consider that their side may be flawed.
Hannah Arendt observed,
This insight remains disturbingly relevant in today’s political climate. When truth becomes malleable, political divisions deepen, and citizens become more susceptible to manipulation by figures who blur the lines between reality and fabrication. The emergence of a Trumpian cult of personality exemplifies this environment. Trump’s face, emblazoned on T-shirts, posters, and MAGA paraphernalia, has become a symbol of loyalty. His phrases and mannerisms have taken on a near-divine significance, portraying him as a “silverback leader,” an almost prophetic figure among his supporters. This messianic image was only reinforced after an assassination attempt, with rally-goers donning ear bandages in a cringeworthy display of allegiance disguised as solidarity. Trump’s cult of personality is unique within Western democracy, where the proliferation of choices would theoretically dilute such singular loyalty. Yet the West has a penchant for celebrity worship-a trend that Trump, as a former reality TV star turned political demagogue, has expertly leveraged.
In some respects, Trump’s rise mirrors the cults of personality surrounding authoritarian figures like Stalin, Mao, and even Hitler. And to pre-empt his supporters’ inevitable outrage, let me clarify. I am not equating Trump with Hitler or Stalin in ideology or actions, but rather pointing to the cult-like following each managed to inspire. Trump’s demagoguery, however, does carry fascistic undertones that disturbingly align with historical precedents. His approach, as well as that of his European counterparts on the radical right, embodies an authoritarian appeal that seeks to bypass nuanced policy in favour of a simplified-and often dangerous-vision of governance. Just as the British Union of Fascists once capitalised on societal unrest building up to WW2, today’s radical right parties exploit anxieties around immigration, national identity, and economic uncertainty. The dynamics of these movements echo historical patterns, with riots and protests fuelled by an idealised image of national purity-a dangerous regression to past ideologies that led to some of history’s darkest chapters.
Demagogues frequently exploit societal fears, reducing complex issues into simple, divisive narratives that polarise populations. Historically, leaders like Aaron Burr exemplify this approach. Burr’s ambition alarmed figures like Alexander Hamilton, who feared that Burr would prioritise power over constitutional order, using divisive tactics and disregarding democratic principles.
The founding fathers of the United States were acutely aware of the dangers posed by demagogues. They designed systems like the Electoral College as initial safeguards against such figures. Over time, however, the filtering functions intended by the framers have eroded, as the Electoral College has become more ceremonial and less a gatekeeper against manipulative leaders. The founders’ concern was not solely personal ambition, but the way demagogues could corrode democratic institutions by fostering distrust in government and dividing the populace.
It is crucial to recognise that tendencies towards demagoguery, divisive rhetoric, and authoritarianism are not confined to the right. The left is equally capable of wielding these tactics. The term “fascism,” traditionally associated with the right, is not exclusive to it. Far-left revolutions, from the French Revolution onward, have employed strategies as repressive and ideologically rigid as those linked to fascism. The left’s culture of “cancelling” dissenters and enforcing ideological conformity mirrors the coercive strategies of far-right fascists. Despite its claims of tolerance, the left is often guilty of silencing dissent in ways that eerily resemble the authoritarianism it decries on the right.
Project 2025 exemplifies a right-wing approach to governance that flirts with elements of fascism. Similarly, the tactics of Antifa and its affiliates exhibit fascistic tendencies, though from the opposite side of the political spectrum. It is time to acknowledge that authoritarianism and extremism are not confined to one side, but increasingly pervasive across the ideological landscape. Denying this reality only perpetuates the rise of such rhetoric, granting authoritarianism a foothold in societies that once prided themselves on freedom and tolerance.
Even within a robust democracy like the United States, fascistic tendencies can take root, though the strength of American institutions presents a formidable obstacle. Despite efforts by demagogues to stack the administration and bureaucracy with loyalists, these institutions remain a bulwark against totalitarianism-for now. Yet complacency is dangerous. If we continue indulging in cults of personality, disinformation, and demagoguery, we may one day find that even the strongest institutions are not immune to the insidious allure of authoritarian rule.
From the book, The Rise of the Radical Right.






