Populism, Propaganda, and the Manipulation of Rhetoric
If one considers the basic definition of political populism, any simpleton might perceive it as a positive phenomenon. The Conversation defined populism in a 2019 article, “What Actually is Populism?”, as a:
“…political style that claims to speak for the people against an elite establishment.”
Populism is not confined to any specific segment of the political spectrum-it manifests strongly at both extremes, left and right. A politician who persistently invokes the notion of ‘the people’ can feel oddly reminiscent of Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson’s wrestling promos from the 1990s.
The reason populism carries such negative connotations ties back to the concept I’ve previously discussed: the tyranny of the majority. I am not a politician, so I have no reason to temper my words. The truth is that ‘ordinary people’-your average Tom, Dick, and Harry, whose thoughts revolve around getting laid, the weekend football match, and the soap opera they consume nightly after a monotonous day under their employer’s thumb-rarely possess the intellectual faculties for critical thinking, the analytical consumption of news, or the open-mindedness necessary to embrace those who are different. Nor do they have even a rudimentary understanding of politics, let alone political philosophy or theory, required to make informed decisions about who might be the most competent, forward-thinking leader in an election. I won’t elaborate further here, as I address this issue in greater depth in my essay on the uninformed voter.
Populists exploit those who lack insight-those who let emotion triumph over reason when voting. They thrive on their ability to use deceptive language to manipulate the gullible. Their rhetoric invariably suggests there is a simple solution to every problem, appealing to those who crave clarity amidst the chaos. Yet, the promise of simplicity in politics is a fallacy. Politics is rarely simple; no problem has a straightforward solution.
Demagogues have mastered a rhetorical art that aligns perfectly with populism: sophistry. The Oxford English Dictionary defines a sophist as someone who employs clever but false arguments, often with the intent to deceive. Demagogues deploy sophistry at every opportunity-during election campaigns, debates, and interviews-all in service of their pursuit of power.
Demagoguery itself hinges on political leadership that appeals to emotions, fears, and prejudices rather than reason. Demagogues often say foolish things, not because they are fools, but because they are addressing a foolish audience-one easily swayed by hyperbolic speeches and conspiratorial claims. Cicero encapsulated this dynamic brilliantly:
In other words, people-whether in elections or casual conversations-are drawn more to emotion, spectacle, and flattery than to facts, evidence, or reason.
One mustn’t underestimate the demagogue. Some may think they are unclever because they speak foolishly, using outlandish claims and crude language, but they are far from stupid. They are adept at speaking the language of their audience, manipulating the emotions that their voters cannot regulate, and exploiting their lack of critical thinking. The demagogue knows how to rile up the crowd and revel in its gullibility, taking full advantage of it.
The public is fickle and docile, eager to believe almost anything if it comes from a charismatic, prestigious figure-it reinforces their pre-existing worldview, especially when confirmed by the crowd. Yet even the most captivating individual can only achieve so much on their own. The crowd is indispensable. The gullible quickly accept a false consensus simply because it aligns with popular opinion. Propaganda facilitates this false consensus, deliberately thrust into public consciousness as people navigate their society. Truth and reason are discarded, and the leaders responsible for this propaganda fervently hope they never return. For their authoritarian control to persist, they need people to think exactly as they are told.
From the book, The Rise of the Radical Right.






